...
Well, looks like you can return stuff through half.com, which sucks because the other five discs work fine, but it's not likely this person just has a #4 replacement lying around. Oh well. You get what you pay for. At least there's not an episode on that disc I'm dying to see -- just Sloane getting tortured by Quentin Tarantino and the introduction of Sark. Although in one of those eps, Syd does ask out Vaughn, and there is the priceless line "Did the Clinton administration teach you nothing?" Alas.
If I do end up sending it back, I'll watch the last two discs first (might as well) and then put the returned $30 towards a legit copy of S2. Then S1 can go on my Christmas list. Mwahaha.