tv // lbd // shoulder touch

Another something special

***Warning Will Robinson... rantage ahead...***

I think they're still discussing this over on the awards list, but seeing as how I'm in the minority and don't have the energy nor the inclination to talk myself blue in the face over there... I'll do it over here *eg*

An awards category - nay, multiple categories - specifically for Meridian fix-it fic. Ye god.

Apparently Meridian is special, seeing how as, unlike any other episode, it hath impacted fic writers from all walks of life (slashers, genners, and all three Janet/Daniel shippers -- *grins and runs from Wrath of Sue*).

Now okay. Meridian is the only episode concerning a main character's flittering off like a radioactive squid. This is true. But from what I understand of the term 'fix-it fic', we're not talking about a category dealing with stories exploring the episode (like my fic, Between the Dark and the Daylight. Yeah, I'm shameless, but it's my LJ *g*). We're talking about fics from people who didn't like how the episode went and so rewrote it.

This is very common. It's called 'episode based fic'. And maybe there's been a lot of it for Meridian; I don't know. I read fic from SJers and good gen writers, who don't obsess over Meridian or His Radioactive Squidliness. But for the sake of argument, say there is. There have been other episodes that have generated a lot of fic... shouldn't they all get their own categories? If we're talking about volume, or popularity, I can rattle off a handful of episodes that are special enough.

Really, let's just call it what it is... a Daniel Tribute category. And all the little prolific obsessives can come nominate their most favoritist stories where Daniel survives thanks to his own great goodness and Jonas dies a horrible death while the other members of SG1 (Jackums, the black guy and the blonde chick) stand around sporadically touching Daniel to remind themselves of his existence and great goodness.

And then we can make it so the winning stories for Best Jack-Best Sam-Best Teal'c-Best Jonas fic are actually stories about Daniel. But wait, we've already done that.
  • Current Mood: irritated irritated
Rant away, dahling ;)

Just to play devil's advocate (denialites' advocate? bleh *g*) I can tell you what they'd say... that Daniel is special because he's the only main character not still on the show. Which is true, and I said that in my initial post and everything. I just... don't... really... care. They're more than welcome to make up their own Daniel Jackson Memorial Fanfiction Awards. I would be perfectly perfectly happy for them to do that. I just don't want to see the SG1 Awards turn into the DJMFA ;)

Cause say it with me now... 'Stargate does not revolve around His Squidliness'.

As for Jonas bashing actually having some intelligent reasoning behind it -- tis a vain hope, me dear *bg
As for the awards, I find it worrying that there are enough ecentric Daniel fans out there to make a caterogry like this even a slight possibility...

You know, I said exactly the same thing about Sam/Jack fics when we first started the Awards back in 2001.

The Awards are run on two major principles: to serve the entire fandom, which unfortunately includes those we think must be watching some totally different show, and to offer, as far as possible, a level playing field for all candidates going in.

You might think of it in that light, actually - if we do offer a Meridian category, it will be as much to keep those fics from swamping the rest of the Awards, as to please the SDJ crowd.

Or would it be better to leave the lists as they are, and let Meridian-fixes win in every single category?
You know, I said exactly the same thing about Sam/Jack fics when we first started the Awards back in 2001.

Oh yeah. I totally see the similarities there.

Or would it be better to leave the lists as they are, and let Meridian-fixes win in every single category?

Hmm... Daniel stories overrunning everything, namely the gen categories... and this would be different from the last two years how?
Or would it be better to leave the lists as they are, and let Meridian-fixes win in every single category?

So, basically you're intimating now that the Meridian-fixes are gonna win no matter what - regardless of whether they have their own category or not. Question: are we even going to ATTEMPT the whole awards process this year (nominating, voting, etc), or are we just gonna skip straight to the handing-out-all-awards-to-SDJers part?

No, what I'm saying is that the Awards are a democratic process, and whether I like it or not, the people who are going to vote for that particular kind of fic are in the (vocal) majority.

The team do everything we can to level the playing field. Yep, Daniel fics have dominated in the past. That's because ultimately more people vote for those stories. Based on that, and based on my own observations of the fandom over the past year, unless SDJ decided to boycott the Awards for some reason, SDJ is likely to dominate again.

So all we can do is try to level it out. The rest is really up to the rest of the fans. Ultimately, the team don't control the Awards. If you don't like the results, don't blame the team.